Durango Bill’s
Debunking the Deniers of Global Warming
Global Warming Denial
Liars
The “Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine”
(It’s actually Arthur Robinson’s farm in very rural Oregon)
The “Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine” (OISM)
advertises itself as “a non-profit research institute”. Global
Warming Deniers frequently promote the “Oregon Petition” which is
one of the OISM’s products. In reality, the Oregon Institute of
Science and Medicine is a farm in very rural Oregon some 6 linear
miles southeast of Cave Junction, Oregon. (Population ~1,425
http://www.city-data.com/city/Cave-Junction-Oregon.html
)
Its founder/owner, Arthur B Robinson, promotes the
“Robinson Curriculum” - a “Jesus-Plus-Nothing-Else” home-school
system.
(Please copy and paste both of the following 2 lines for the full
URL.
http://web.archive.org/web/20120414173008/
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/robinsonusers4christ/
Group appears to have become defunct in the last few years.).
Isn’t it amazing how the Internet can be used to
transform a farm into the “Oregon Institute of Science and
Medicine”? (It appears that Arthur Robinson may well have
registered his farm as “a non-profit research institute” to avoid
taxes. Wikipedia:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Art_Robinson
“Robinson is the president of the OISM,
[4] which is a
501(c)(3) non-profit organization located in Cave Junction,
Oregon.” )
“The prestigious sounding institution with which they
were affiliated—the Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine—was
elsewhere revealed to be a one-room operation located on a farm
on a rural road in the forested foothills of the Siskiyou
Mountains. It consisted only of Arthur B. Robinson, a chemist
with a Ph.D. in chemistry from the California Institute of
Technology, and his 21-year-old son, who has no advanced degree
(Hill 1998).”
(Please copy and paste both of the following 2 lines for the
full URL.)
http://sciencepolicy.colorado.edu/admin/
publication_files/resource-1892-2005.50.pdf
The following pictures show where the farm (Oops: the “Oregon
Institute of Science and Medicine”) is located.
The first picture (via Google Earth) shows the
Pacific coastline. All of Oregon is included as well as pieces of
neighboring states. The pin marks the location of the “Oregon
Institute of Science and Medicine” (OISM)
In this next picture, we zoom in on rural
southwestern Oregon. The town of Cave Junction (population ~1,425)
is now visible. The pin marking the location of the OISM is about
6 linear miles to the southeast of the small town.
Zooming in still further shows the OISM pin on the
right side of picture in the middle of what looks deceptively like
a farm. Dick George Road is near the left edge of the picture, and
somebody has applied the name “Science and Medicine Rd” to the
access road to the farm. Closer inspection via Google Earth shows
that “Science and Medicine Rd” is a dirt road, and you can even
make out weeds and grass growing in the center of the road between
the usual tire paths.
If you check the address of the “Oregon Institute of Science and
Medicine”, it is usually given as:
2251 Dick George Road
Cave Junction, OR
This final Google Earth picture zooms in on the farm
(oops: “Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine” ) itself.
There’s the usual home and a few satellite
buildings/storage sheds. Also of note is the large building that
can be seen above the center of the picture. Google Earth has a
ruler tool which can be used to measure the distance between any
two points. If you zoom in closely, you can measure the size of
any object. For example: a building.
The size of this particular building is about 100 x
58 feet (+/-). Farms have lots of farm equipment (tractors,
harvesters, etc.) and frequently have large buildings to store the
equipment out of the rain. (Cuts down on rust, etc.) We also note
that the shadow from this building is longer than the shadows from
other buildings. Thus this building is taller than the other
buildings.
With a little imagination you could give your storage
building a fancy name. You could even hang a sign on the side of
your building to make it look impressive. With a little more
imagination, you might even come up with something that looks
like:
Note the lack of windows. Buildings that have space
for ordinary people usually have windows, but then again, farm
equipment doesn’t need windows. However, to drive farm equipment
in and out would require oversized doors, and it looks like there
are a couple of two-story doors as well as two other doors for
human use.
The picture above is a Google Earth “Street View” of
the intersection of Dick George Road and “Science and Medicine
Rd”. In turn, Science and Medicine Rd. leads to the “World Famous”
“Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine”. And then again, maybe
it’s a private driveway, complete with electronic gate to exclude
anyone except the owner (and invited guests).
The Robinson Curriculum
If you go to the Oregon Institute of Science and
Medicine’s home page at
http://www.oism.org/
, one of the links that shows up on the left side of the page is
“Robinson Curriculum”.
Clicking on this link leads to:
http://www.oism.org/s32p28.htm
The “Dr. Robinson” link on this page confirms that
the OISM is a 350-acre farm in southern Oregon. There is also
another link at the top of the page that continues to:
http://www.robinsoncurriculum.com/
There is another route to get to:
http://www.robinsoncurriculum.com/
Start at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/RobinsonUsers4Christ/, and
part way down the page you will find a link to the same
http://www.robinsoncurriculum.com/.
The
“RobinsonUsers4Christ • Discipling Our Children for God's
Glory”
Yahoo Group states:
“This group is for Bible and Trinity-believing,
God-fearing, "Jesus-Plus-Nothing-Else" Christian families using
or investigating the Robinson Curriculum. All homeschooling
families using or investigating the Robinson Curriculum are
welcome to join, with notice that the group is first and
foremost a Christian group.”
Thus, the main field of study for the Oregon
Institute of Science and Medicine is “Jesus-Plus-Nothing-Else”
home schooling. At one time this home schooling even extended to
Islamic/Muslim home schooling.
(Please copy and paste both of the following 2 lines for the full
URL.
http://web.archive.org/web/20061117221744/
http://www.muslimhomeschool.com/mhsnr/DOCS/models.htm
Q: And what is Arthur Robinson’s view on regular education?
A: “Public education (tax-financed socialism) has become the most
widespread and devastating form of child abuse and racism in the
United States.”
“Can this problem be corrected? Yes. Can it be corrected by
improving the public schools? No – only by abolishing them.”
(Please copy and paste both of the following 2 lines for the full
URL.)
http://whoisartrobinson.defazioforcongress.org/
2010/09/15/art-robinson-public-education-child-abuse-and-shou/
For more information about the “Oregon Institute of Science and
Medicine” (alias “The Farm”) please see:
http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Oregon_Institute_of_Science_and_Medicine
The Arthur Robinson Interview
on the Rachel Maddow Show
It’s one thing to read about Arthur Robinson, but
it’s something else to see Arthur Robinson “live”. In 2010, Arthur
Robinson was the Republican candidate for Oregon’s 4th district
representative to the U. S. House of Representatives. As a
political candidate, he was interviewed on msnbc’s Rachel Maddow
show. Whether intentional or not, Robinson did a great
impersonation of “Captain Queeg” in the famous Caine Mutiny
courtroom scene. (A paranoia meltdown for anyone not familiar with
the movie.) The only missing props were “the marbles”. Robinson
appears to have lost them.
http://mgx.com/blogs/2010/10/07/maddow-art-robinson-vs-defazio/
“Holy moly! What a complete whack job, Art Robinson is!”
The Oregon Petition
While the “Oregon Institute of Science and
Medicine” appears to be a farm and has been active in
“Jesus-Plus-Nothing-Else” home schooling, they have still had left
over time to push a political agenda on Global Warming. The
“Oregon Petition” has been thoroughly debunked by others at:
1)
http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Oregon_Institute_of_Science_and_Medicine
2)
http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2007/10/oregon-institute-of-science-and-malarkey/
3)
http://sciencepolicy.colorado.edu/admin/publication_files/resource-1892-2005.50.pdf
4)
http://rabett.blogspot.com/2006/12/gift-for-john-h.html
Readers are encouraged to check out these other web sites, but a
quote from the last source pretty much sums it up:
We may agree with Robinson and Robinson
on one point. There may be more serious issues than global
warming that threaten continued advances in the quality of life
for humankind. One of these is the attempt by Robinson and
Robinson to misinform the general public about the scientific
process and what is known and unknown in the frontiers of
science.”
Beginning in 1998 Arthur Robinson, Noah Robinson
(Arthur’s son), Frederick Seitz, and Willie Soon began to promote
a “Global Warming Denier”, politically inspired statement that is
popularly known as the “Oregon Petition”.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oregon_Petition
As described at
http://www.desmogblog.com/new-oregon-petition-promoter-not-sufficiently-rational-to-advise-tobacco-industry the argument for the petition is:
“This exercise is so flawed that it's hard to know
what demands criticism the most. First, the whole exercise is
being pushed by Arthur B. Robinson, the survivalist, Darwin
skeptic and proprietor of something called the Oregon Institute
of Science and Medicine. The "scientific" article on which the
petition rests is authored by Robinson, his son Noah, and the
American Petroleum Industry-funded Willie Soon , none of whom
could hope to get their climate work published in a
peer-reviewed science journal.”
The “Oregon Petition” was introduced and promoted by
Frederick Seitz who at one time was a respected scientist.
However, during the 1970s he went to work for the tobacco
companies to write “scientific articles” (corporate propaganda)
that cigarette smoke was completely harmless. By 1989, even the
executives at Phillip Morris described him as: “Dr. Seitz is quite
elderly and not sufficiently rational to offer advice”.
(Original picture at
http://tobaccodocuments.org/pm/2023266534.html?pattern=fred%5Ba-z%5D%2A%5CW%2Bseitz%5Ba-z%5D%2A&#p1
)
As described at the desmogblog.com post:
“So, 18 years ago, Seitz was "not sufficiently
rational" to meet the lenient scientific standards of the
tobacco industry, but today, Art Robinson still feels it's
ethical to send out a petition over Seitz's signature on one of
the most pressing current scientific issues of the day.”
"It's pathetic that they're so desperate to show that any
scientist supports their position that they're even contacting
random graduate students in tangentially and unrelated fields."
- Sean Lake, graduate student in the UCLA Department of Physics
and Astronomy.
And as described by Snopes:
https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/30000-scientists-reject-climate-change/
"The petition was created by individuals and groups
with political motivations, was distributed using misleading
tactics, is presented with almost no accountability regarding
the authenticity of its signatures, and asks only that you have
received an undergraduate degree in any science to sign."
The “Oregon Petition” Song
(Use the melody from “Old MacDonald had a Farm”)
Arthur Rob’son had a
farm,
Old MacDonald had a farm,
in rural
Oregon.
E I E I O.
And from this farm he made a
list, And on this farm he
had a cow,
in rural
Oregon.
E I E I O.
With a name name
here
With a moo moo here
and a name name
there
and a moo moo there
Here a name, there a
name,
Here a moo, there a moo,
everywhere name
name
everywhere moo moo
Arthur Rob’son had a
farm,
Old MacDonald had a farm,
in rural
Oregon.
E I E I O.
Arthur Rob’son had a
farm,
Old MacDonald had a farm,
O I S and
M.
E I E I O.
And from this farm he made a
list, And on this farm he
had a pig,
O I S and
M.
E I E I O.
With a name name
here
With an oink oink here
and a name name
there
and an oink oink there
Here a name, there a
name
Here an oink, there a oink
everywhere name
name
everywhere oink oink
Arthur Rob’son had a
farm,
Old MacDonald had a farm,
O I S and
M.
E I E I O.
Return
to the main Global Warming Denial Liars main page
Web page generated via Sea Monkey's Composer HTML editor
within a Linux Cinnamon Mint 18 operating system.
(Goodbye Microsoft)